Re: Re: Galileo and alt-AIDS 11 February 2005
Previous Rapid Response Next Rapid Response Top
Tony Floyd,
Medical Student
Newcastle University

Send response to journal:
Re: Re: Re: Galileo and alt-AIDS

Julian Turningheart has written:

> he regurgitates (without references!) the tired, Catholic-bashing canard of Conventional Wisdom that Galileo was “ostracized”...

That is correct, no reference was provided. mea culpa.

And then...

> Galileo was vehemently suspected of heresy, not “ostracized”...

For which, (perhaps as an example of what not to do?) Mr Turningheart hasn't, well, provided a reference.

Having an inconsistent and unscientific theory for which you have no evidence does not entitle you to wear the 'I AM LIKE GALILEO YOU'RE ALL PICKING ON ME' badge.


Competing interests: None declared