Re: Re: Galileo and alt-AIDS 11 February 2005
Previous Rapid Response Next Rapid Response Top
Tony Floyd,
Medical Student
Newcastle University

Send response to journal:
Re: Re: Re: Galileo and alt-AIDS

Julian Turningheart has written:

> he regurgitates (without references!) the tired, Catholic-bashing canard of Conventional Wisdom that Galileo was “ostracized”...

That is correct, no reference was provided. mea culpa.

And then...

> Galileo was vehemently suspected of heresy, not “ostracized”...

For which, (perhaps as an example of what not to do?) Mr Turningheart hasn't, well, provided a reference.

Having an inconsistent and unscientific theory for which you have no evidence does not entitle you to wear the 'I AM LIKE GALILEO YOU'RE ALL PICKING ON ME' badge.

***

Competing interests: None declared